historical records / conformation records
Reserve Best in Show Winners
| YEAR | DOG | BREED | OWNER(S) | JUDGES |
| 1911 | Prince of York | Airedale Terrier | G.W. Batson | *Not Recorded |
| 1912 | CH. Warren Distinct | Smooth Fox Terrier | Winthrop Rutherfurd | Dr Henry Jarrett Ralph C English Charles Lyndon |
| 1913 | Vickery Estelle | Wire Fox Terrier | Vickery Kennels | "Dr Henry Jarrett G Muss-Arnolt Theodore Offerman, Referee" |
| 1914 | CH. Vickery Fast Freight | Wire Fox Terrier | Vickery Kennels | Midgeley Marsden |
| 1915 | Wireboy of Paignton | Wire Fox Terrier | George W. Quintard | Dr Henry Jarrett |
| 1916 | Conqueror *reported as Best of Opposite Sex to the BIS winner | Scottish Terrier | Miss Jean B. Crawford | "Charles G Hopton Frank F Dole Vinton P Breese Fred Senn W H Whittem" |
| 1917 | CH. Slumber | Old English Sheepdog | Mrs. Tyler Morse | George S Thomas |
| 1918 | Phantom of Ashcroft | Pekingese | Elbridge Gerry Snow, Jr. | "Vinton P Breese Charles G Hopton George S Thomas, Referee" |
| 1919 | CH. Haymarket Faultless | Bull Terrier | R.H. Elliott | "Harry T Peters Theodore Offerman J Willoughby Mitchell" |
| 1920 | CH. Lansdowne Sunflower | Greyhound | Mrs. B.F. Lewis | "Thomas S Bellin William E Warne Norman K Swire" |
| 1921 | CH. Phantom of Ashcroft | Pekingese | Elbridge Gerry Snow, Jr. | "Norman K Swire Charles G Hopton Dr J D De Mund, Referee" |
| 1922 | CH. Lansdowne Sunflower | Greyhound | Mrs. B.F. Lewis | "G Muss-Arnolt Vinton P Breese Theodore Offerman" |
| 1923 | There was no BEST IN SHOW award in 1923. The American Kennel Club barred interbreed competition for 1923 except in the Miscellaneous Class. Comprehensive new rules for Group & Best in Show judging were adopted effective for 1924. | |||
| 1924 | CH. Dolf Von Dusternbrook *reported as 2nd in BIS competition | Shepherd Dog | Josselle Kennels | "Norman K Swire Walter H Reeves" |
| 1925 | War Bride of Davishill | Airedale Terrier | Davishill Kennels | "Walter S Glynn Theodore Offerman Robert A Ross Ralph C English" |
| This award was discontinued in 1925. Beginning in 2013, new American Kennel Club rules required the awarding of Reserve Best In Show. | ||||
| 2013 | Bugaboo’s Picture Perfect | Old English Sheepdog | Colton and Heather Johnson | Mr Michael J. Dougherty |
| 2014 | GCH Brighton Lakeridge Encore | Standard Poodle | Toni Sosnoff & Martin Sosnoff | Mrs Betty Regina Leininger |
| 2015 | GCH Cragsmoor Good Time Charlie | Skye Terrier | Victor Malzoni Jr. & Cragsmoor Kennels, Reg. | Hon. David Merriam |
| 2016 | CH Belisarius Jp My Sassy Girl | Borzoi | Mai Ozeki | Dr. Richard Meen |
| 2017 | GCH Vermilion’s Sea Breeze | Irish Setter | Sandra Nordstrom & Bruce & Mary Foote | Mr Thomas H. Bradley 3d |
| 2018 | GCH Ingebar's Tynan Dances With Wildflowers | Giant Schnauzer | Sandra Nordstrom & Carol Mann & Maryann Bisceglia | Mrs. Betty-Anne Stenmark |
| 2019 | GCHG CH Oeste's In The Name Of Love | Havanese | Mary E King & Rafe H Schindler & Julie Vogel & Taffe McFadden | Mr. Peter Green |
| 2020 | GCHG CH Pinnacle Kentucky Bourbon | Whippet | Justin Smithey & Dr Ken Latimer & Judy Descutner & Nancy Shaw & Cheslie Smithey | Mr. Robert H. Slay |
| 2021 | GCHG CH Pinnacle Kentucky Bourbon | Whippet | Justin Smithey & Dr Ken Latimer & Judy Descutner & Nancy Shaw & Cheslie Smithey | Mrs. Patricia Craige Trotter |
| 2022 | GCHP Fox Canyon's I Won the War at Goldshield CGCA CGCU TKN | French Bulldog | Sandy Fox & Morgan Fox & Perry Payson & Alexandra Vorbeck | Dr. Don Sturz |
| 2023 | GCH CH Pequest Rum Dum | Pekingese | David Fitzpatrick | Ms. Elizabeth Sweigart |
